Article

Chambers of Labour under renewed discussion

Published: 27 April 2000

In the Austrian "social partnership" system, the Federal Chamber of Labour (Bundesarbeitskammer, BAK) and its regional organisations in the nine federal states (Länder), the Chambers of Labour (Arbeiterkammern, AK s) represent labour – along with the Austrian Trade Union Federation (Österreichischer Gewerkschaftsbund, ÖGB).

As Austria's Chamber of Labour held elections in spring 2000, a new debate about their finances and possible reforms was initiated by the populist Freedom Party, which forms part of the new coalition government. The Chambers' leadership now fears that their organisational rights might come under severe pressure at a time of substantive reform in the country's economic and social system.

In the Austrian "social partnership" system, the Federal Chamber of Labour (Bundesarbeitskammer, BAK) and its regional organisations in the nine federal states (Länder), the Chambers of Labour (Arbeiterkammern, AK s) represent labour – along with the Austrian Trade Union Federation (Österreichischer Gewerkschaftsbund, ÖGB).

Organisation, membership and finances

BAK is the umbrella organisation of the regional Chambers of Labour, performing general representative functions, while the regional Chambers are responsible for most service functions (see below). BAK is entitled to advise state authorities on all matters affecting employees' interests and serves as a "think-tank" for ÖGB, while the latter enjoys a de facto monopoly of representation in collective bargaining. BAK and ÖGB represent the interests of employees in a cooperative manner, and their complementary relationship is manifested in the fact that the organisational structure of the Chambers is regional, whereas ÖGB's is primarily sectoral.

In spring 2000, elections are to be held to the Chambers' general assemblies at both the federal level (Hauptversammlung) and the regional level (Vollversammlungen), according to the Chambers' statute. Following an amendment of the law regulating Chamber of Labour procedures (Arbeiterkammergesetz) in 1998, several changes will come into effect in this election. The amendment simplifies the election procedure by allowing a longer period for elections, voting in companies and postal voting. On the employers' side, similar elections are also being held in the Chamber of the Economy (Wirtschaftskammer Österreichs, WKÖ), which started in March (AT0004217N). Representatives of both sets of Chambers are elected every five years.

In the Chamber of Labour elections, the competing factions maintain close ties with the political parties in parliament. The leadership and administration of BAK and the AKs are traditionally dominated by the faction affiliated to the Social Democratic Party (Sozialdemokratische Partei Österreichs, SPÖ), which has formed a highly influential group in the Chambers. However, the Chambers in the western Länder, Vorarlberg and Tirol, are dominated by the Österreichischer Arbeiter- und Angestelltenbund (ÖAAB), the affiliate of the conservative Volkspartei (ÖVP).

Unlike ÖGB, the Chambers of Labour were established by law and membership is also specified by law, being obligatory for all employees, apprentices, persons occupied with childcare and unemployed people. However, several distinct groups of employees are exempted from AK membership, such as "leading employees" (eg managers or members of company boards) or certain professions practised on a self-employment basis (eg lawyers and pharmacists), with the latter being represented by specific Chambers. Furthermore, employees of various institutions and administrative bodies in the public sector are also exempted from AK membership.

In general, the AK represents about 87% of all 3.1 million employed persons in Austria - see the table below. As indicated by the table, the largest regional AK is that in Vienna, with some 700,000 members and a budget of more than ATS 1 billion. It can be seen as the most influential Chamber, and its president is traditionally also the elected president of BAK. In order to finance their expenditure, all regional Chambers are authorised to levy contributions (Kammerumlage) from their members, though unemployed persons and those in training are exempted. The amount of contributions is determined by the general meeting (Hauptversammlung) of the BAK, and may vary up to 0.5% of gross pay, with a fixed maximum ceiling. Thus the level of contribution payments is limited and an individual member need pay no more than about ATS 130 per month, while the average monthly contribution is currently ATS 60 . As shown by the budget figures in the table below, about 90% of the total expenditures of all Chambers together are covered by the Kammerumlage. Except the Burgenland AK, where revenues from the Kammerumlage cover 83.5% of the total budget, members' contributions account for more than 90% of the budget in all other individual Chambers. Other income comes from interest payments and various other sources. At total of 2,600 people are employed by the AKs.

Membership, revenues and budget of the Chambers of Labour
Chamber (regional and federal level) Membership Revenues (Kammerumlage) * Total budget *
Vienna 700,000 925 1,027
Oberösterreich 490,000 576 601
Niederösterreich 430,000 518 543
Steiermark 400,000 435 454
Tirol 220,000 274 333
Salzburg 200,000 230 238
Kärnten 160,000 195 212
Vorarlberg 119,000 153 169
Burgenland 70,000 71 85
Austria (total) 2,789,000 3,377 3,662

* Estimates for 2000 in millions of ATS.

Source: Austrian Press Agency ( APA ), AK.

Services and representational functions

The Chambers of Labour provide a broad range of services for their members, including individual support and advice in all fields affecting employees. Aside from services, they act as interest organisations representing labour, mainly vis-à-vis the state. In 1998, more than 200 legislative drafts were reviewed by BAK.

In particular, the Chamber of Labour cover the following range of activities:

  • provision of advice and information for individual members regarding specific fields, such as unemployment, social insurance (pensions), consumer protection, taxes, women's issue, families and apprentices;

  • assistance in legal procedures, mainly labour court proceedings, with a total of some 10,000 cases a year involving disputes over a total of about ATS 1.5 billion, and other interventions for members, as well as legal advice in all fields related to labour law;

  • provision of free training services and financial assistance for training and education;

  • scientific analysis of economic, social and educational questions;

  • participation in the Austrian system of social partnership, which includes representation of employees in a variety of "corporatist" boards and commissions, and consultation in the course of developing economic and social legislation;

  • development of solutions for essential economic and social questions in cooperation with ÖGB and the employer's organisations;

  • representation of labour at the European Union level; and

  • representation of consumers' interests.

Discussions and disputes

In recent years, BAK and the AKs have repeatedly come under pressure from political parties, especially from the populist Freedom Party (Freiheitliche Partei Österreichs, FPÖ), which targeted the alleged privileges of certain AK representatives and their perceived unwillingness to reform the Chambers. Recently, the new ÖVP-FPÖ coalition government (AT0002212F) has proposed a reduction of employee contributions to the Chambers of Labour (Kammerumlage) by arguing that this helps to lower non-wage labour costs: the FPÖ is calling for a reduction in the contribution from 0.5% to 0.3% of gross pay, implying a cut in the Chambers' budget of 40%. This measure is seen as a compensation for the planned increase in the employees' contribution for the public health insurance system. The current AK president, Herbert Tumpel, has rejected the possibility of any reductions. Since this renewed criticism of the Chambers comes just at the same time as proposals for a new pensions reform have been presented by the new government (AT0002211N), BAK now fears that this debate was launched in order to weaken the representational powers of BAK in particular, and of organised labour in general.

Commentary

Information so far available on the outcomes of the regional AK elections in 2000 indicates that representatives who have opposed the new government's reform programme could increase their share of the vote considerably. Candidates of the social democratic faction appear to be the main winners. At the same time, under the new government, organised labour has significantly lost influence in public policy-making, in contrast to the position of business interests. This runs counter to Austria's traditional forms of "symmetrical policy concertation" based on the principles of social partnership, that gave both organised business and labour a paramount role in economic and social policies. With the recent debate on contributions to the Chambers of Labour, the new government has begun to target representational issues of high importance for labour, in addition to the substantive issues (namely the reform of the welfare state) already under discussion. Moreover, there is a tendency to fuse representational and substantive issues: as noted, the demand for reductions in the contribution for the Chambers of Labour is justified by the need to reduce non-wage labour costs and to finance the public health insurance system. There is a high risk that linking representational and substantive issues will magnify conflicts over any kind of reform. At worst, this may give rise to adversarial relations, thus marking a watershed in Austria's labour relations that have been famous for their outstanding pattern of cooperation and social peace. (Angelika Stueckler, University of Vienna)

Eurofound recommends citing this publication in the following way.

Eurofound (2000), Chambers of Labour under renewed discussion, article.

Flag of the European UnionThis website is an official website of the European Union.
European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions
The tripartite EU agency providing knowledge to assist in the development of better social, employment and work-related policies